Home » Courts

Courts

Articles

Court: Evidence needed to enforce CID

The Indiana Attorney General must provide at least a verified petition to a court to enforce a civil investigative demand and show the demand is proper, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled today.In Nu-Sash of Indianapolis, Inc. d/b/a McKee Sunroom Designs v. Steve Carter, Indiana Attorney General, and Liberty Publishing, Inc. d/b/a Booster Club Productions, No. 49S02-0801-CV-16, Nu-Sash appealed a trial court order that the company respond within 10 days to a civil investigative demand (CID) issued by Attorney General Steve Carter regarding…

Read More

Tax Court upholds agency’s loan decision

The Indiana Tax Court has upheld a state agency’s decision approving loans to fund fire department operations in a Morgan County township.In Virginia Perry and Gregg Terhune, et al. v. Indiana Department of Local Government Finance, et al., No. 49T10-0712-TA-78, the court affirmed the DLGF’s approval of two Madison Township loans – a reduced $409,000 emergency amount for operating expenses and $650,000 for new vehicles and equipment – that the petitioning taxpayers didn’t want to pay for in 2007. Those taxpayers argued…

Read More

Court: private cause of action allowed

Tackling an issue of first impression, the Indiana Court of Appeals determined the “Equal Access Law” in Indiana Code creates a private cause of action for bail agents. In Dave Galloway in his capacity as Hendricks County Sheriff v. David Hadley, d/b/a D & D Bonding, No. 32A-04-0707-CV-400, Galloway appealed the trial court order granting Hadley a preliminary injunction against the use of a “preferred agent list” by the Hendricks County Sheriff’s Department. The list contains the names of preferred bail agents,…

Read More

Merged conviction violates double jeopardy

The Indiana Court of Appeals vacated a defendant’s conviction of conspiracy to deal methamphetamine because it violated Indiana’s double jeopardy law, but the court affirmed his conviction and sentence for dealing methamphetamine. In today’s ruling in Robert R. Gregory Jr. v. State of Indiana, No. 15A01-0708-CR-348, Gregory raised several issues on appeal, arguing evidence supporting his convictions was obtained before police had a valid search warrant, a witness’s testimony shouldn’t have been allowed at trial, there was prosecutorial misconduct, and his…

Read More

Justice encourages judicial applications

An Indiana Supreme Court justice is in South Bend today to actively encourage attorneys to apply for an opening on the St. Joseph Superior Court that will be available when Judge William T. Means retires Sept. 30.”Being a judge is a challenging but enormously gratifying way for an attorney to use all of his or her legal skills in a way that improves both the quality of life in our community and the quality of justice in our state,” Justice Frank…

Read More

Judges rule on marital property division

Trial courts that order parties to sell marital residences can take into account any needed repairs and costs associated with selling residences when figuring the value, as long as those amounts are based on evidence in the record, the Indiana Court of Appeals decided today.A unanimous three-judge appellate panel ruled today in David Keown v. Cynthia Marie Keown, No. 49A02-0706-CV-496, a Marion County case in which the ex-husband challenged a trial court’s decision in recalculating the value of the marital residence as…

Read More

Justices to hear ‘robocalls’ arguments Monday

The Indiana Supreme Court travels to Terre Haute Monday for arguments in a case dealing with “robocalls.” The issue in State of Indiana v. American Family Voices, Inc., Jim Gonzalez, and John Does 2-10, is whether pre-recorded, automated “robocalls” with political content can be limited under Indiana’s Automatic Dialing Machine Statute, Indiana Code Section 24-5-14-5.The case stems from complaints about American Family Voices’ use of automated calls; the attorney general’s office filed an action against the group in September 2006 in…

Read More

Child support abatement starts on petition date

The Indiana Court of Appeals reversed a trial court order setting the date in which an incarcerated man can receive an abatement in his child support, finding the date the man filed his order was when it could be first applied. The ruling could open the door for the Indiana Supreme Court to decide when an abatement can take effect.In In re the marriage of: Gary Becker v. Heather Becker, No. 49A04-0804-CV-205, Gary Becker appealed the trial court order modifying his…

Read More

Court urges early review of offender litigation

An Indiana state prison inmate has filed dozens of lawsuits with claims that a painful odor violated his constitutional rights, he’s been repeatedly denied access to public records, victimized by excessive force, and not given proper treatment behind bars.The Indiana Appellate Clerk’s Office has 35 of Eric D. Smith’s appeals, most being civil suits that include one decided today, and six that remain pending awaiting action.Today, the Indiana Court of Appeals dismissed one of the 29-year-old’s string of suits and the…

Read More

International law CLE to be webcast

A free CLE program featuring discussion about the international prosecution of war crimes, genocide, and crimes against humanity will take place in the Indiana Supreme Court’s Courtroom from 3 to 4:30 p.m. May 7. Event organizers have received enough RSVPs to fill the room, but stand-by reservations are still being accepted as of today for what planners say is a short waiting list so far.This program has been approved for 1.5 CLE credit hours. For those unable to make it, there…

Read More

Justices to demonstrate electronic ticketing

Two Indiana Supreme Court justices will be on hand in Indianapolis tomorrow for a demonstration of a new, statewide electronic ticketing system.Chief Justice Randall T. Shepard and Justice Frank Sullivan will join Indianapolis Public Safety Director Scott Newman and law enforcement to show how the new system will work. Called eCWS – electronic Citation and Warning System – the new mobile system allows police to create tickets electronically and send them to a central location for law enforcement, prosecutors, and courts…

Read More

Election choices fade for Marion Superior Court

Three unslated contenders for Marion Superior judgeships have withdrawn their names from the May primary ballot, including two sitting judges who between them have almost a half-century of judicial experience.By the noon deadline on Feb. 25, incumbent Marion Superior Judges Kenneth H. Johnson and Gary L. Miller withdrew their names after filing their candidacies late last week. Both were overlooked at the county Republican Party’s slating convention Feb. 16.Indianapolis attorney Angela Dow Davis, who’d filed to run against the Democrats’ slate also chosen…

Read More

Larry Bird sues over use of name

Former college and NBA basketball star and current president of basketball operations of the Indiana Pacers Larry Bird has filed a trademark infringement suit in federal court against the owners of his childhood home. Bird filed the suit, Larry Bird v. Legend of French Lick LLC, No. 4:08-CV-0070-DFH-WGH, in the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Indiana, New Albany Division Monday against Georgianna Lincoln and Christopher Cooke, who purchased Bird’s childhood home in French Lick from the Larry Joe Bird Revocable…

Read More

Court sponsors Northwest Ordinance lecture

The Indiana Supreme Court is sponsoring a lecture celebrating the 221st anniversary of the Northwest Ordinance of 1787 and the legal issues related to Indiana’s southern borders established by the ordinance. The lecture will begin at 3 p.m. on July 14.Seating in the Supreme Court’s courtroom for “221 Years of Unsettled Borders: Indiana and the Northwest Ordinance” is no longer available for the free lecture, but a monitor and overflow seating will be available in the atrium area, as well as…

Read More

Judges disagree over ‘access’ in statute

Indiana Court of Appeals judges were split in their ruling today on a man who was convicted of performance harmful to minors, with the majority affirming the conviction.In Frederick A. Zitlaw v. State of Indiana, No. 29A05-0701-CR-35, Zitlaw appealed the trial court’s denial of his motion to dismiss the performance harmful to minors charge, a Class D felony. A Hamilton County sheriff’s deputy saw Zitlaw expose himself in a public park. The probable cause affidavit alleged children were present in the park….

Read More

SCOTUS makes history, shoots down gun ban

Answering a 217-year-old constitutional question, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a historic ruling this morning that the Second Amendment protects an individual’s right to have a gun in his or her home.The ideologically split 5-4 decision in District of Columbia, et al. v. Heller, No. 07-290, struck down a city handgun ban in Washington, D.C., and defined the scope of the gun rights amendment to the U.S. Constitution for the 21st century.Specific to this case, the court affirmed a Circuit Court ruling…

Read More