Opinions

7th Circuit Court of Appeals
Shannon McHenry v. Nancy Berryhill
18-1691
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division. Magistrate Judge Matthew P. Brookman.
Civil. Vacates an administrative law judge’s dismissal of Shannon McHenry’s application for disability insurance benefits, finding the ALJ failed to acquire a medical expert to review a consequential MRI report. Remands for proceedings.

Indiana Court of Appeals 
Andrew W McWhorter v. State of Indiana 
33A01-1710-CR-2415
Criminal. Affirms Andrew McWhorter’s conviction for Class A felony voluntary manslaughter. Finds the Henry Circuit Court did not abuse its discretion in admitting video testimony from a deceased eye-witness. Also finds McWhorter’s due process rights were not violated during his prior trial, nor was he subjected to double jeopardy. Judge L. Mark. Bailey dissents with a separate opinion.

Indiana Court of Appeals
Roderick Vandrell Lewis v. State of Indiana,
18A-PC-767
Post-conviction. Affirms denial of post-conviction relief petition. While agreeing with Roderick Lewis that his attorney’s performance at sentencing was deficient, concludes Lewis’s 130-year sentence for his conviction of felony murder would not have been different if counsel had offered the mitigating circumstances raised at the post-conviction hearing. Finds the post-conviction court correctly determined that Lewis was required to establish prejudice under Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 688, 694 (1984) rather than U.S. v. Cronic, 466 U.S. 648 (1984). Also holds appellate counsel was not ineffective.

Indiana Court of Appeals 
City of Gary, Indiana and Gary/Chicago International Airport Authority v. Auto-Owners Insurance Company
18A-CT-68
Civil tort. Affirms the Lake Superior Court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of Auto-Owners Insurance Company, a liability insurer for one of the defendants in a lawsuit seeking payment for cleaning up contaminated property. Finds the city’s complaint focused solely on the operation of Western Scrap and did not allege facts that might fall under the Auto-Owners policies that covered Recycle West. Also rules Auto-Owners designated sufficient evidence to make a prima facie showing that negated the airport’s separate contamination lawsuit. 

Indiana Court of Appeals
Douglas L. Leistner v. State of Indiana (mem. dec.)
18A-CR-491
Criminal. Affirms Douglas Leistner’s 40-year sentence for conviction of two counts of Level 1 felony child molesting and Class A misdemeanor public voyeurism. Finds the trial court erred when it refused to find Leistner to be a sexually violent predator. Remands to the Dubois Circuit Court to correct this error and enter a finding that Leistner is a sexually violent predator.

7th Circuit Court of Appeals
The Medical Protective Company of Fort Wayne, Indiana v. American International Specialty Lines Insurance Company, now known as AIG Specialty Insurance Company
18-1737
Appeal from the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, Fort Wayne Division
Judge James T. Moody
Civil. Affirms Medical Protective Co. should have known that it was facing a potential claim. Reverses and remands grant of summary judgment in favor of AISLIC. Finds there is a genuine dispute of material fact as to whether MedPro should have settled with the Bramlett family for $200,000.

7th Circuit Court of Appeals
Gloria Terry v. Gary Community School Corporation
18-1270
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, Hammond Division. Magistrate Judge John E. Martin.
Civil. Affirms the district court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of Gary Community School Corporation against Gloria Terry’s claims of sex discrimination. Finds Terry did not provide evidence showing the district had a pretextual, discriminatory purpose for its actions in giving the principal position to a male candidate instead of her. Finds she was not discriminated against based on her sex, nor was she paid less in violation of Title VII and the Equal Pay Act.

Indiana Court of Appeals 
Alberto Baiza Rodriguez v. State of Indiana
20A03-1704-CR-724
Criminal. Reaffirms the original holding that the Elkhart Superior Court erred in finding Alberto Baiza Rodriguez had waived his right to seek modification of his sentence imposed pursuant to a fixed plea agreement. Finds the 2018 amendments to Indiana Code section 35-38-1-17 and 35-35-1-2 were not intended to apply retroactively, and even if they were, such an application would unconstitutionally impar Rodriguez’s contractual rights under his plea agreement with the state. Remands for further proceedings. Senior Judge Robert Rucker dissents with separate opinion. 

Indiana Court of Appeals 
Matthew Edward Greer v. State of Indiana
18A-CR-404
Criminal. Affirms Matthew Greer’s conviction for Level 1 felony child molesting; Level 3 felony vicarious sexual conduct; Level 4 felony incest; Level 6 felony performing sexual conduct in the presence of a minor; and Class A misdemeanor resisting law enforcement. Finds the prosecutor did not commit misconduct during D.G.’s deposition, and Greer failed to establish fundamental error.

Indiana Court of Appeals 
Kelly Sickafoose v. Mary Beery, Auditor of Adams County
18A-MI-1549
Miscellaneous. Affirms the denial of Kelly Sickafoose’s motion for rule to show cause why the Adams County auditor should not be held in contempt. Finds the Adams Superior Court did not err in the denial and that Sickafoose’s filings were frivolous. Also finds an award of appellate attorney’s fees is warranted. Remands to the trial court for a determination of the amount of appellate fees that should be awarded to the auditor. Judge Mark Bailey dissents with separate opinion. 

Indiana Court of Appeals 
Riley M. Randall v. State of Indiana
18A-CR-1574
Criminal. Affirms Riley Randall’s conviction for Level 3 felony robbery while armed with a deadly weapon. Finds the DeKalb Superior Court did not abuse its discretion in denying Randall’s proposed jury instruction on the duress defense because that defense was not available to Riley. 

The following 7th Circuit Court of Appeals opinion was posted after IL deadline Friday:
USA v. Edward Bishop
18-2019
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, South Bend Division. Judge Robert L. Miller Jr.
Criminal. Affirms Edward Bishop’s conviction of discharging a firearm during a drug transaction. Finds the warrant authorizing the search of his cellphone did not violate the Fourth Amendment’s requirement that every warrant “particularly describ[e] the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”

The following 7th Circuit Court of Appeals opinions were posted after IL deadline on Thursday:
Lorenzo D. Roundtree v. Jeffrey E. Krueger, United States Penitentiary, Terre Haute
14-3696
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Terre Haute Division. Chief Judge Jane E. Magnus-Stinson.
Civil. Affirms the district court’s rejection of Lorenzo Roundtree’s attack on his life sentence for selling heroin that led to a user’s death. Finds that the 7th Circuit has recognized that Burrage v. United States cannot be used to litigate under 28 United States Code section 2241 if 18 U.S.C. 2255 could have been or was used to raise the issue, so because Roundtree unsuccessfully challenged his sentence under section 2255 in the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals, relief under section 2241 is not available in the 7th Circuit.

Indiana Court of Appeals 
Collins Asset Group, LLC v. Alkhemer Alialy
18A-CC-1160
Civil collection. Affirms the Hamilton Superior Court’s dismissal Collins Asset Group, LLC’s complaint against Alkhemer Alialy. Finds that the trial court did not err in granting Alialy’s motion to dismiss. Also finds the trial court correctly concluded that CAG’s action was barred by the six-year statute of limitations pursuant to Indiana Code section 34-11-2-9.

Indiana Supreme Court
Kevin Andrew Schuler v. State of Indiana
31S00-1703-LW-134
Life without parole. Affirms the Harrison Superior Court’s conviction of Kevin Shuler for murder. Finds Shuler’s Miranda rights were not violated, there was sufficient evidence to support his 65-year sentence, and Shuler’s sentence is appropriate. Remands for a new, more specific sentencing statement consistent with Harrison v. State.

Indiana Supreme Court
Lori Barcroft v. State of Indiana
18S-CR-135
Criminal. Affirms Lori Barcroft’s conviction of guilty but mentally ill in the murder of Jaman Iseminger. Finds that evidence of Barcroft’s demeanor, taken together with the flaws in the expert opinion testimony and the absence of a well-documented history of mental illness, was sufficient to support an inference of sanity. Also finds that a factfinder may discredit expert testimony and rely instead on other probative evidence from which to infer a defendant’s sanity. Justice Christopher Goff dissents with separate opinion, which Justice Geoffrey Slaughter joins.

7th Circuit Court of Appeals
United States of America v. Robert D. Taylor
18-1545
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, New Albany Division. Judge Tanya Walton Pratt.
Criminal. Affirms Robert Taylor’s sentence of 135 months in prison for his conviction of one count of possession of child pornography. Finds the government did not breach Taylor’s plea agreement and fulfilled its obligation to advocate for a within-guidelines sentence. Also finds Taylor’s stipulations in the agreement waived his right to appeal two sentencing enhancements. Finally, finds the district court did not err in sentencing Taylor.

Indiana Court of Appeals 
James E. Jarman v. State of Indiana
18A-CR-1034
Criminal. Reverses James E. Jarman’s convictions for methamphetamine, dealing in a synthetic drug or synthetic drug lookalike substance and possession of paraphernalia. Finds although Jarman signed a waiver consent to searches without a warrant or probable cause, he did not “unambiguously authorize” suspicionless searches of his person. 

Indiana Court of Appeals
Brian Harold Connor v. State of Indiana
18A-CR-442
Criminal. Reverses Brian Connor’s conviction of Class C misdemeanor operating a motor vehicle with an alcohol concentration equivalent to at least 0.08 grams of alcohol but less than 0.15 grams of alcohol per 210 liters of the person’s breath. Finds the Marion Superior Court abused its discretion in admitting Connor’s chemical breath test into evidence when an Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department captain administered the test using a procedure not approved by the Department of Toxicology.

Indiana Court of Appeals
Anonymous Physician, Anonymous Medical Practice, Anonymous Hospital v. Michelle Kendra, as Personal Representative of the Estate of John Kendra, Deceased
18A-CT-323
Civil Tort. Reverses the Lake Superior Court’s denial of summary judgment in favor of Anonymous Physician, Anonymous Medical Practice and Anonymous Hospital. Finds Michelle Kendra’s knowledge of her father’s heart problems and suffering after he was implanted with a pacemaker was enough to trigger a duty to investigate the possibility of medical malpractice.